Decision details

Stell Bank Replacement (North of Borrowby, Area 2) – Decision to Award

Decision Maker: Corporate Director of Environment

Decision status: Recommendations Approved

Is Key decision?: No

Is subject to call in?: No

Decision:

Award of the contract for Stell Bank Replacement works for £194,040 to Thomas Armstrong (Construction) Limited through the CECF 2021.

Reasons for the decision:

A procurement exercise was carried out using the CECF 2021. Thomas Armstrong proved to be the lowest price compliant bid for the scheme.

A replacement structure at Stell Bank on an improved road alignment has been deemed the most cost effective way of dealing with numerous defects on the bridge as well as regular parapet damage.

The works form part of the highway capital programme for 2024-25.


Alternative options considered:

Defects in the arch could be dealt with by casting a concrete saddle, however a previous widening using an exposed steel beam is at the end of service life and would require replacement, combined with the poor road and water course alignment it is more cost effective to replace the structure on an improved alignment rather than improving what is already there.


Publication date: 15/07/2024

Date of decision: 11/04/2024